The Best Mattress Toppers Tested by Editors (2026)

If you feel like you’ve tried everything but you still aren’t sleeping through the night, it might come down to the fact that your mattress isn’t comfortable enough. It’s a tough truth to confront, but the good news is, you can completely change your current mattress’s feel with a mattress topper. There are toppers for every kind of sleeper, and we tested them all to find the best mattress toppers for your preferences.

In our Best List series, Apartment Therapy editors test household products to find the very best. We’ve tested mattresses, bed blankets, pillows for side sleepers, and more. Now we’re testing mattress toppers across all categories — ranging in price, material, feel, and more — to find the best ones for every single preference. Check out our findings below!

There are a few things you need to consider while looking for the best mattress toppers, including the type of fill, thickness level, and sleeping style. Additionally, mattress toppers and mattress pads are different — mattress toppers sit on top of your mattress to provide extra cushioning, while mattress pads (or protectors) are thin coverings that protect your mattress from fluids, allergens, and dust mites.

That said, some mattress pads add the support, cushion, or temperature regulation you may need without the height of a topper. For this reason, we’ve included a few high-performing mattress pads that achieve these functions in addition to mattress toppers.

It’s recommended that you replace your mattress topper every three to five years, simply because it’s a thinner version of the multi-layer thickness of a mattress, so it will wear faster with regular use.

If you want to add extra height to your bed, consider foam and latex mattress toppers. Most toppers are about two inches thick, but you can find options that are four inches and higher. The main benefit of a thicker mattress topper is extra cushioning, which can mean both softness as well as support — if you have a seriously lumpy mattress, a two-inch topper might not be enough to make you comfortable. Make sure your fitted sheet has sides that are long enough to fit over both your mattress and your topper if you go this route.

There are a few material and textile certifications we mention that are worth looking out for when shopping for bedding of any kind, including mattress toppers.

To find the best mattress toppers out there, we tested a wide range of models and judged them on the following criteria:

Craving cool, plush comfort? The Sleepyhead Super Topper is your best bet. Sold in two-inch and three-inch options, the topper is made of gel- and copper-infused memory foam to ensure a comfortable night’s sleep. In addition to its cooling effect, the topper offers optimal pressure point relief, along with a hint of added height, which makes any bed look that much more regal.

Another enormous bonus is that it comes with a cooling, washable cover, so you don’t have to worry about cramming the entire topper in the washing machine. It also is equipped with an anti-slip bottom so it won’t budge during the night.

“I was presently surprised by this topper,” says Charli, AT’s editor-in-chief. “It’s very cozy, yet it offers great support, great cooling effects, and lots of pressure relief. I tried it in the full size for our guest room and our recent overnight guests asked where it came from — they want their own at home!”

Who It’s Best For: Those looking for a mattress topper that’s easy to care for; sleepers who run hot.

If you aren’t afraid to splurge but still want a solution that’s cheaper than buying a whole new mattress, head over to Nolah. The brand’s Microcoil Mattress Topper will drastically change the feel of your mattress for more reasons than one.

Firstly, it contours to your body and relieves pressure everywhere. Similar to a hybrid mattress, it provides support using a combination of foam and flexible coils. To top it all off (get it?), the interior is wrapped in a cover that’s designed to keep you cool all night long.

“This topper completely elevated my sleep experience,” says former commerce assistant editor Morgan, who tested the plush version. “I’ve never had a topper that strikes a balance between supportive and cushioned so perfectly. The thickness and added height are great, and it isn’t difficult to fit sheets around it. Most importantly, my back pain has lessened, and even just sitting on the edge of my bed is so much more comfortable now.”

Who It’s Best For: Those who want to make their mattress feel completely different; those who want to sink into their bed, but still be supported.

TEMPUR-Pedic is the OG memory foam mattress company, and it was only a matter of time before they released a mattress topper, too. Like the brand’s popular mattresses, the TEMPUR-Adapt Topper features three inches of TEMPUR Material and is designed to cradle every contour of your body.

The pressure relief it offers is next level, hence why nearly 11,000 shoppers swear by the product. That and the fact that it comes with Staytight corner straps, a removable, machine-washable cover, and the option to add cooling technology. 

“If you’ve wanted to try a TEMPUR-Pedic mattress, but shied away from the cost, the TEMPUR-Adapt Topper is the next best thing,” says Senior Shopping Editor Britt. “As someone who’s slept many nights on the TEMPUR-Cloud Hybrid Mattress, the comparison checks out! Thanks to the topper’s built-in straps, a mattress protector, and a fitted sheet, it was like the TEMPUR-Adapt was simply an extension of my mattress that elevated it in both size and comfort.

The topper maintained its cozy support and conformed to me, no matter how I slept. [And] considering that the TEMPUR-Adapt Topper can also be used separately from your bed as an added layer of comfort for a sleeper sofa or even the floor, you get a lot out of it for the price.”

Who It’s Best For: Those looking for an extremely comfortable, easy-to-care-for, body-conforming mattress topper. 

*Honorable Mention: Another option from the brand that we’d be remiss not to mention is the ultrasoft TEMPUR-Cloud Topper. “I’ve noticed a significant change in my sleeping pattern,” Ayanna, our assistant social editor, says. “I actually sleep through the night now. With my previous mattress topper, I would wake up daily in the middle of the night. What surprised me was that for its height, it’s still so comfortable to sleep on.”

The Puffy Deluxe Mattress Topper is applauded by hundreds of shoppers, as well as our team of testers. The top-rated topper is sold in six sizes and two firmness levels and is made of hypoallergenic memory foam, making it a suitable pick for just about any sleep preference.

That said, what makes this topper really stand out is its fitted sheet design. Rather than corner straps (or no securing mechanism at all), the Puffy Deluxe Mattress Topper is built into a removable deep-pocket fitted sheet that accommodates most mattresses up to 15 inches thick. And since the cover is removable, you can ensure that your topper stays clean and hygienic by simply tossing it in the wash every couple of weeks along with your sheets. 

“I was incredibly impressed with this mattress topper,” says brand activation coordinator Reece, who adds that his opinion still stands a year later. “I gave up on mattress toppers for a long time after never being able to find one that I love. I love a perfect balance of soft and firm and this topper is exactly that. My bed is 10x comfier with this mattress topper!”

Who It’s Best For: Those looking for a super secure topper; those who enjoy the option to choose between firmnesses.

Microcoil is a solid route to take if you’re after a mattress topper that’s as supportive and durable as it is sinkable. Brooklyn Bedding’s version — a brand that has impressed us with its mattresses before — receives high praise from our former commerce SEO editor Sarah, who opted for the firm feel.

The micro coils will hug every contour of your body, accommodating every move you make. It also has a cooling cover that hot sleepers are sure to love, as well as open foam technology that draws away body heat. All the while, its durable construction will keep it from sagging, so you won’t have to replace it (or your mattress) any time soon.

“This mattress topper is the perfect mix of cooling and supportive,” says Sarah. “I went with the firm option to help make up for the sag of an older mattress below and the support this gives is incredible. Top that off with the cooling aspect of the cover and it’s the perfect way to upgrade your bed without shelling out for a whole new mattress.”

Who It’s Best For: Those who value support and want to invest in a topper that will last.

If fluff is number one on your must-have list, a pillow top option is the way to go. The Company Store is one of our editors’ go-to’s for bedding, so it doesn’t surprise us that its mattress topper made the list. Stuffed with a down alternative fill, it’s ideal for those with down sensitivities — as well as those who crave a super cushioned sleeping experience. It’ll add four inches of loft to your bed, and every time you lay down, you’ll sink right into it. The quilted construction keeps the material evenly distributed. 

“It feels like truly sleeping on a cloud,” says AT’s principal product manager, Anna, who gave the Legends Hotel topper top marks when it came to comfort. It’s also so fluffy that she notes “at first glance [it] could totally pass as a down comforter.” She also has no doubts about its longevity — though, to keep it in tip-top shape, the brand recommends avoiding the washing machine.

Who It’s Best For: Those who prioritize loft and fluffiness over firmer support.

*Honorable Mention: Another option we couldn’t leave out is SERTA’s Down Illusion Pillowtop Mattress Topper. AT contributor Holland says her goal is always to have her bed feel like a cloud, and this option didn’t disappoint. “I love how it includes a stretch grip fabric that wraps around your mattress like a sheet does, so I don’t have to worry about the mattress topper pulling up my fitted sheet throughout the week as I sleep like my old down topper did,” she explains. “It’s also nice and soft without being super bulky.”

We’ve found Parachute’s luxurious bedding to be top-of-the-line, and its cushioned mattress topper is no exception. The brand compares it to falling into a “marshmallow-stuffed cloud” every night, and our former shopping writer Nikol would agree. In her review, she mentions that it gives the impression of laying on a huge fluffy pillow.

This mattress topper provides all of the benefits of down without being authentic down, which will prevent any allergies from acting up. It adds three inches of height to your bed. It’s all encased in an ultra-soft cotton shell, which never hurts even if it’s underneath your sheets.

As a side sleeper, I was so used to having empty gaps between my limbs and the mattress. But this topper rose to fill those uncomfortable spaces and made me feel truly supported all over,” Nikol says. “I don’t think I’ll ever take it off my bed!”

Who It’s Best For: Shoppers who are allergic to regular down or are looking for an ultra-cushioned topper.

If you prefer to fill your home with eco-friendly products, the Earthfoam Mattress Topper is the perfect pick for you. Made of natural wool, organic cotton, and believe it or not, rubber from trees. While a tree may not seem like the most comfortable sleep surface, the Earthfoam Mattress Topper proves otherwise with its cozy two-inch design that cradles and supports curves while relieving pressure points. And that’s without even having a securing mechanism to keep it in place. 

“I’ve only slept on this a few nights so far, but it hasn’t budged once (major, coming from a severe tosser and turner), and makes me even more excited to get into my bed — which I didn’t think could be possible, TBH,” says AT’s former senior style editor Blair.

“I also have a fairly low-to-the-ground platform bed frame, sans box spring, so I love that the topper has added a little extra height and gives my bed a more ‘sophisticated’ look overall. And best of all, my current queen-size sheets and quilt still fit on top perfectly, even with the added thickness.”

All in all, Blair says that “if you’re looking for a firm-but-not-too-firm, built-to-last, not-overly thick organic mattress topper that can make any bed feel brand new, night after night, this is the one.” Just be warned: This topper is so cozy that in addition to enticing you to hop in bed early, it might make getting out of bed that much more difficult. 

Who It’s Best For: Those who value eco-friendly construction. 

The Shopping Team at Apartment Therapy Media has one mission: to help you make smart and informed purchases. We know how hard online shopping can be — it’s literally our job! From trying to decipher confusing marketing lingo to sorting through scores of fake paid reviews in search of some truth, online shopping can be overwhelming. We’re dedicated to doing the hard work for you by reviewing these products firsthand and delivering all the information you need, both good and bad.

As experts in the home and design space, we put products to the test right where they matter: at home. Whether it’s the gadget on everyone’s wish list or the coolest-looking design finds, we bring these products into our personal spaces and test them for weeks and even months at a time to see how well they live up to their claims. Do those sheets still feel silky smooth after a couple of washes? Does that mattress remain firm or soften up too soon? Are those bath towels really quick drying or do they need an extra spin in the machine? We’ll let you know. 

Within each of our reviews, we also break down the different ways that we critique products. In some cases, we’re testing products head-to-head on things like price, ease of use, and durability. In others, we’re comparing new products to personal favorites or ones we’ve tested in the past. No matter what, we’ll always break down the ins and outs of a product. At the end of the day, we’re consumers too, so we’ll provide you with all the information we’d want — and then some.